
ATM9 or ATM10? Both come from the All the Mods team, both end in a long quest line with a proper endgame, and a world cannot move from one pack to the other. So the choice matters before your group builds anything. This comparison uses the packs' own files, checked on 3 November 2026: the CurseForge release lists, the client manifests and the official server files of ATM9 1.1.1 and ATM10 8.4.
Quick answer: For a new world, pick ATM10. It runs Minecraft 1.21.1 on NeoForge with around 500 mods, needs Java 21 and got version 8.4 on 29 October 2026, its 18th release this year. ATM9 runs Minecraft 1.20.1 on Forge with over 400 mods and Java 17, and has not changed since 1.1.1 on 12 October 2025. Stay on ATM9 if you already have a world there or want its GregTech, Thermal and Botania progression. For a server, both packs ship the same 8 GB Java heap, so both need a 12 GB plan to start.
ATM9 vs ATM10 at a Glance
| ATM9 | ATM10 | |
|---|---|---|
| Minecraft version | 1.20.1 | 1.21.1 |
| Mod loader | Forge 47.4.0 | NeoForge 21.1.265 |
| Newest version (3 November 2026) | 1.1.1, 12 October 2025 | 8.4, 29 October 2026 |
| Releases in 2026 so far | None | 18 |
| Mods | Over 400 (418 jars in the server files) | Around 500 (469 jars in the server files) |
| Java | 17 | 21 |
| Java heap in the server files | -Xms4G -Xmx8G | -Xms4G -Xmx8G |
| Server files | 1.14 GB download, 1.29 GB unpacked | 1.26 GB download, 1.45 GB unpacked |
| Rendering mods in the client pack | Embeddium and Oculus | Sodium and Iris |
| Total CurseForge downloads | 13.7 million | 22.8 million |
ATM10 is not new any more: its first public file came out in August 2024. What separates the two packs in late 2026 is the mod list, the Minecraft version underneath and how often each one still changes.
What Is Different in the Mod List
The core is the same in both packs: Create, Applied Energistics 2, Mekanism, Ars Nouveau, Refined Storage, Ender IO, Immersive Engineering, Mystical Agriculture, Powah, Occultism, Apotheosis, Productive Bees, Twilight Forest, The Aether and Allthemodium. ATM10 runs newer builds of them, for example Create 6.0.10 against 6.0.6 in ATM9.
The differences that change how you play:
- Only in ATM9: GregTech CEu Modern, the Thermal Series and Botania. ATM9's CurseForge page dares you to craft the ATM Star and take on the Gregstar. ATM10 8.4 ships no GregTech, no Thermal and no Botania at all, neither in the client pack nor in the server files.
- Only in ATM10: among others Modern Industrialization, Oritech, Just Dire Things and Actually Additions, none of which are in ATM9 1.1.1. Industrial Foregoing, on the other hand, is in both packs.
- Vanilla content: ATM10 sits on Minecraft 1.21.1, so you get the Tricky Trials content: Trial Chambers, the Breeze, the Mace, the Crafter and Wind Charges. ATM9 on 1.20.1 has none of it.
If Botania or GregTech is the reason you play ATM, that settles it: ATM9. Looking for one specific mod? Search the file list on the ATM10 CurseForge page before you commit.
Is ATM9 Better Than ATM10?
Neither is better on paper. They are at different points in their life.
ATM9 is finished. Its last three releases were 1.0.8 (22 April 2025), 1.1.0 (11 September 2025) and 1.1.1 (12 October 2025), and nothing has come out in the year since. For a long-running server that is an advantage: recipes, quests and configs stay as they are, and every guide written for 1.1.1 still applies.
ATM10 is still moving. It had three releases in just over five weeks: 8.2 on 22 September, 8.3 on 15 October and 8.4 on 29 October 2026. Updates can change recipes, add mods and need the same client version on every player's PC. That is fine for a group that starts a fresh world now and updates together. On a public server where players expect the world to stay the same, it is more work. Back up the world before every pack update, whichever pack you run.
On the client, ATM10 renders through Sodium and Iris, ATM9 through Embeddium and Oculus. Frame rate depends mostly on your PC, render distance and shaders, so it is no reason on its own to pick one pack over the other. Try both if it matters to you.
ATM9 vs ATM10 Server Requirements: RAM per Player Count
Neither pack publishes player counts or official RAM advice for servers. The one memory number in their files is the Java heap: ATM9 1.1.1 and ATM10 8.4 both ship a user_jvm_args.txt with -Xms4G and -Xmx8G, followed by the same 18 G1 garbage collector flags. Java needs memory on top of the heap for itself, so keep the heap at about 80 to 85 percent of the server's RAM, as in our exit code 137 guide. That makes 12 GB the smallest server that runs either pack as it ships. An 8 GB server would have to run the pack below its own heap, for ATM9 as much as for ATM10.
| Server RAM | ATM10 group | ATM9 world | Set -Xmx to | Standard | Premium | Disk (Standard / Premium) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 GB (MC Special 1) | 1 to 5 players | Fresh world or small group | 10G | €10.80 | €21.99 | 70 GB / 100 GB |
| 16 GB (MC Special 3) | 5 to 15 players | Grown world, big automation | 13G to 14G | €14.40 | €27.99 | 85 GB / 130 GB |
| 32 GB (MC Special 4) | 15+ players | Public server, many teams | about 26G | €29.99 | €56.99 | 120 GB / 165 GB |
These are the plan sizes on our ATM10 server hosting and ATM9 server hosting pages, not official ATM figures. Prices are per month in the Netherlands, Germany and Poland, including VAT, as of 3 November 2026. ATM9 gives no player counts at all, so its column follows the stage of the world. Big automation, chunk loaders and several busy dimensions can move you up a row before the player count does.
Raise -Xmx in user_jvm_args.txt when you move to a bigger server. If the server starts through that file, Java never uses more than 8 GB, however much RAM you have.
CPU and Disk
Kitchen-sink modpacks lean hard on single-thread speed, so one fast core matters more than many cores, for ATM9 and ATM10 alike. In the Netherlands, Germany and Poland our Standard tier runs on an AMD EPYC 7443 and Premium on a Ryzen 9 9950X; the CPU is shared on every plan.
Disk is the smaller worry. The server files unpack to 1.29 GB (ATM9) and 1.45 GB (ATM10) before Forge or NeoForge installs its libraries and before the world starts to grow. Every chunk you pre-generate, as below, is stored on that disk too, so keep an eye on free space while it runs.
ATM9 Java Version vs ATM10
Mojang's version files list Java 17 for Minecraft 1.20.1 and Java 21 for 1.21.1, and both start scripts enforce that. ATM9's startserver.sh stops with "Minecraft 1.20.1 requires Java 17" when it finds anything older than 17. ATM10's stops with "Minecraft 1.21 requires Java 21" below 21. Check what your machine has:
java -version
For ATM10 the first line has to show version 21 or newer, such as openjdk version "21.0.x". Looking further ahead: All the Mods 11 is still in beta (0.13.0-beta from 27 October 2026) on Minecraft 26.1.2, which needs Java 25.
JVM Flags: G1 for ATM9, ZGC as an Option for ATM10
Both packs ship Aikar's G1 flags, the set that the PaperMC docs publish, in user_jvm_args.txt, and both startserver.sh scripts start Java with @user_jvm_args.txt. That is the file to edit, not a line with a server.jar.
On ATM10's Java 21 you can switch to Generational ZGC, a collector built for short pauses on large heaps. Replace the flag lines in user_jvm_args.txt with these, here for a 12 GB server:
-Xms4G
-Xmx10G
-XX:+UseZGC
-XX:+ZGenerational
On Java 21 the -XX:+ZGenerational line is what turns the generational mode on; from Java 23 that mode is the default and Java warns that the flag is deprecated. ATM9 runs on Java 17, where Generational ZGC does not exist yet, so keep the shipped G1 flags there and only raise -Xmx. For the trade-offs, see ZGC vs G1GC for Minecraft.
Pre-Generate and Measure: Same Tools, Different Commands
Both packs ship spark (1.10.53 in ATM9, 1.10.124 in ATM10). Run /spark tps for TPS and CPU use, /spark health for memory and disk, and /spark profiler start followed later by /spark profiler stop to see which mod eats the tick time.
Neither pack ships Chunky, but both loaders have a built-in pre-generation command. It needs permission level 4, so run it from the console or as a level 4 operator:
- ATM10 (NeoForge):
/neoforge generate start 0 64 0 188generates a radius of 188 chunks, about 3,000 blocks, around 0, 0./neoforge generate statusshows the progress and/neoforge generate stopends it. - ATM9 (Forge):
/forge generate 0 64 0 10000generates 10,000 chunks in a spiral around 0, 0, about 800 blocks in every direction. Forge counts chunks in total, not a radius.
One more difference: if you start ATM10 with its own startserver.sh and there is no server.properties yet, the script writes view-distance=8 and simulation-distance=5. ATM9's script sets neither, so on ATM9 lower them yourself if the server struggles.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose ATM9 if:
- Your group already has an ATM9 world mid-progression
- You want GregTech CEu, the Thermal Series or Botania in your pack
- You run a long-term server and want a mod list that no longer changes
- A mod you need exists only for Forge 1.20.1
Choose ATM10 if:
- You are starting a new world
- You want Minecraft 1.21.1 content and current mod versions
- You want Java 21 and the option of Generational ZGC on the server
- You do not mind an update every few weeks
Our answer for late 2026: with no world to keep, start ATM10. It is the pack the team still updates, and it needs the same 12 GB server as ATM9. If you are already invested in ATM9, there is no rush to move. Your world and your progression are worth more than a newer mod list, and ATM9 1.1.1 will keep running as it is.
FAQ
Is ATM9 better than ATM10? Not in general. ATM9 is the finished, unchanging pack with GregTech, Thermal and Botania; ATM10 has around 500 mods on Minecraft 1.21.1 and still gets regular updates. For a new world ATM10 is the better start, for an existing ATM9 world there is no reason to switch.
Can I move my ATM9 world to ATM10? No. The packs run different Minecraft versions (1.20.1 and 1.21.1) on different loaders (Forge and NeoForge) with different mod lists, and worlds do not carry over. ATM10 means a new world. If your group wants both, run ATM10 as a second server and keep the ATM9 world where it is.
What Java version does ATM9 use? Java 17. Minecraft 1.20.1 is built for Java 17, and ATM9's start script stops when it finds an older Java. ATM10 is the one that needs Java 21.
How much RAM does ATM9 need compared to ATM10?
On a server, the same: both sets of server files set an 8 GB heap, so start at 12 GB with -Xmx10G. On your own PC, the All the Mods help FAQ says to allocate 8 GB (8,192 MB) and no more than 12 GB (12,288 MB). ATM10's manifest also tells launchers that it recommends 8,196 MB; ATM9's manifest gives no number. For PC specs, see our ATM10 requirements for singleplayer.
Can I run ATM10 on an 8 GB server? Not well. Its server files already set an 8 GB Java heap, and Java needs memory on top of that, so an 8 GB server leaves no headroom and risks being killed for running out of memory. The same goes for ATM9.
Is ATM9 still updated? No new version since 1.1.1 on 12 October 2025 (CurseForge, checked 3 November 2026). The same team keeps updating ATM10, and All the Mods 11 is in beta.
Related guides: ATM10 server requirements, ATM10 RAM calculator, ATM10 JVM arguments, ATM10 Java 21 guide, ATM10 server optimization and the ATM9 server hosting guide.
Sources
All opened on 3 November 2026:
- CurseForge: All the Mods 10 and All the Mods 9 project pages; files lists of ATM10, ATM9 and All the Mods 11
- Official server files: ATM10 ServerFiles-8.4.zip and ATM9 Server-Files-1.1.1.zip (startserver.sh, user_jvm_args.txt, mods folder); client packs ATM10 8.4 and ATM9 1.1.1 (manifest.json)
- All the Mods: help FAQ
- Mojang: version files for 1.20.1, 1.21.1 and 26.1.2; Minecraft Java Edition 1.21
- NeoForge: GenerateCommand.java (branch 1.21.1); Forge: GenerateCommand.java and ChunkGenWorker.java (branch 1.20.1)
- spark: command usage
- OpenJDK: JEP 439, Generational ZGC and JEP 474, ZGC: Generational Mode by Default
- PaperMC docs: Aikar's flags